-
Far from Normal: More Resources for Feedback Informed Treatment in the Time of COVID-19
I hope this post finds you, your loved ones, and colleagues, safe and healthy. What an amazing few weeks this has been. Daily life, as most of us know it, has been turned upside down. The clinicians I’ve spoken with are working frantically to adjust to the new reality, including staying abreast of rapidly evolving — read more
-
Feedback Informed Treatment in the Time of COVID-19
You’ve been busy! Stocking up on food. Telecommuting. Home schooling your kids. And figuring out how you are going to pay bills while not drawing a paycheck or being able to meet with clients face to face. Many clinicians I know are rapidly transitioning to providing services online. As you might imagine, many of those — read more
-
Better Results: Using Deliberate Practice to Improve Your Therapeutic Effectiveness
In 2007, my colleagues and I published an article entitled, Supershrinks: What’s the Secret of their Success? In it, we reported on the status of our then decade long effort to understand why some psychotherapists were consistently more effective than others. Although the phenomenon had first been reported in the mid-1970’s by psychologist David F. — read more
-
Final Making Sense of Making Sense of Negative Research Results about Feedback Informed Treatment
“Everyone understands how a toilet works, don’t you?” ask cognitive scientists Sloman and Fernbach. The answer, according to their research, is likely no. Turns out, peoples’ confidence in their knowledge far outstrips their ability to explain how any number of simple, every day items work — a coffeemaker, zipper, bicycle and yes, a toilet. More troubling, — read more
-
More Making Sense of Negative Research Results about Feedback Informed Treatment
Is it just me or has public discourse gone mad? A brief perusal of social media largely finds accusation, name calling, and outrage instead of exploration, dialogue and debate. Not that any of the latter options were ever simple, straightforward, or successful, but somehow, somewhere, taking a stand has replaced extending a hand. Thus, slightly — read more
-
Making Sense of Negative Research Results about Feedback Informed Treatment
A ship’s captain who successfully sails through a strait at night learns nothing, and adds nothing, to their knowledge of the world. (Please hang with me. I promise this post will not be a long, metaphysical rant). Returning to the example. As paradoxical as it may strike one at first blush, a captain whose ship founders — read more
-
Supervision: Time for a New Way or to Dump the Practice Altogether?
Therapists value supervision. How do we know? Research. In their massive, long-term international study of therapist development, for example, Orlinsky and Rønnestad (2005) found, “practitioners at all experience levels, theoretical orientations, professions, and nationalities report that supervised client experience is highly important for their current and career development” (p. 188). Regulatory boards deem supervision essential, in most jurisdictions — read more
-
Do you ever have “Anticipointment?”
As a mental health professional, how do you approach a New Year? Are you filled with hope for our field? Suffering a twinge (or more) of despair? Maybe you’re in reflective mood, longing for the ‘good ole days’? Or is the difference between December 31st and January 1st just like any other twenty four hour — read more
-
Where did you get that idea?
“I heard Scott Miller say it,” the man sitting next to me said. “Really?” I responded, somewhat incredulous. After all, I didn’t recall ever saying such a thing. More to the point, it’s just not something I would say. Its wrong. Then again, it was clear he didn’t know that I was Scott Miller. Not wanting to — read more
-
Please, don’t use my scales…
Or, at least that’s what I said in response to his question. The look on his face made clear my words caused more confusion than clarity. “But then, how will I found out which of the therapists at my agency are effective?” he asked. “The purpose of FIT,” I replied, “is not to profile, but rather — read more
-
Feedback Informed Treatment: Game Changer or Another Therapeutic Fad?
Remember Beanie Babies? According to one news story, interest was such, “People neglected other areas of their lives to spend all day trading, and some even invested their children’s college funds in toys that they believed would bring an astronomical return on investment.” And how about advertising executive Gary Dahl’s product? You remember him, right? — read more
-
Can you help me understand this?
A couple of weeks ago I received an email from the leader of a group asking me to send them copies of the ORS and SRS. “We are to start using these straight away,” the person wrote. I replied, of course, providing a link to my website where the scales could be downloaded along with — read more
-
Some Common Questions (and Answers) about Feedback Informed Treatment
Mr. Gomm was my sixth grade teacher. Tall and angular, with a booming voice and stern demeanor, he remains a forbidding figure from my childhood. I’ll never forget the day he slammed his open hand on my desk, bellowing “That, Mr. Miller, is an assumption!” Turning abruptly, he walked to the chalkboard, and began writing, one capital — read more
-
Is THAT true? Judging Evidence by How Often its Repeated
I’m sure you’ve heard it repeated many times: The term, “evidence-based practice” refers to specific treatment approaches which have been tested in research and found to be effective; CBT is the most effective form of psychotherapy for anxiety and depression; Neuroscience has added valuable insights to the practice of psychotherapy in addition to establishing the — read more
-
The Skill that Heals, or Kills…
Imagine a power so great that those who possess it are able to heal the sick, and those without it, cause death. By definition, it would qualify as a superpower — and, in fact, one Marvel comic character has claimed this one for their own. More than seven dozen studies have investigated the impact of — read more
-
The Baader-Meinhof Effect in Trauma and Psychotherapy
Have you heard of the “Baader-Meinhof” effect? If not, I’m positive you’ll soon be seeing evidence of it everywhere. That’s what “it” is, by the way — that curious experience of seeing something you’ve just noticed, been told of, or thought about, cropping up all around you. So … You buy a car and suddenly it’s — read more
-
Responsiveness is “Job One” in Becoming a More Effective Therapist
Look at the picture to the left. What do you see? In no time at all, most report a large face with deep set eyes and slight frown. Actually, once seen, it’s difficult, if not impossible to unsee. Try it. Look away momentarily then back again. Once set in motion, the process tends to take — read more
-
Learning Charisma
I entered university an accounting major. My first year, I took all the recommended courses: accounting theory, fundamentals of financial and managerial accounting, and so on. I’d likely be sitting in an office balancing company ledgers or completing tax documents had I never met Hal Miller. A Harvard-educated professor, Dr. Miller taught multiple sections of — read more
-
Do you know Dr. Myron Fox?
Take a good look at the photo to the left. Do you know this person? His name is Myron L. Fox, M.D., a graduate of the Albert Einstein School of Medicine. Still doesn’t ring a bell? At one point, he was the one of the highest rated presenters on the continuing education circuit for physicians, — read more
-
To Give or Not to Give Advice: Is that in Question?
My family and I had a frightening experience this past Memorial Day. While driving through Indiana on the way home to Chicago, our mobile phones began to alert. You know the sound — part cicada, part microphone feedback, but louder. “Tornado warning in this area.” Not a watch, mind you, a warning. The difference is critical. A watch means — read more
-
Therapeutic Nudging: How Very Little Can Mean a Lot
It was a curious finding. One we stumbled on quite by accident. Highly effective therapists were more likely to contact their clients between visits than their more average peers. We wondered whether such behavior might account, at least in part, for their superior retention rates and outcomes? Turns out, our serendipitous finding fit nicely with — read more
-
How Does Feedback Informed Treatment Work? I’m Not Surprised
Feedback-Informed Treatment (FIT) — using measures to solicit feedback about progress and the quality of the therapeutic relationship — is a transtheoretical, evidence-based approach. The most recent research shows clients whose therapists use FIT on an ongoing basis are 2.5 times more like to experience benefit from treatment. But how does it work? Quick. Take — read more
-
What does losing your keys have in common with the treatment of trauma?
Last week, I was preparing to leave the house and could not locate my keys. Trust me when I say, it’s embarrassing to admit this is not an infrequent occurrence. Logic and reason are always my first problem solving choices. That’s why I paused after looking in the kitchen drawer where I am supposed to — read more
-
It’s Time to Abandon the “Mean” in Psychotherapy Practice and Research
Recognize this? Yours will likely look at bit different. If you drive an expensive car, it may be motorized, with buttons automatically set to your preferences. All, however, serve the same purpose. Got it? It’s the lever for adjusting your car seat. I’m betting you’re not impressed. Believe it or not though, this little device — read more
-
Routine Outcome Monitoring and Deliberate Practice: Fad or Phenomenon?
Would you believe me if I told you there was a way you could more than double the chances of helping your clients? Probably not, eh? As I’ve documented previously, claims abound regaring new methods for improving the outcome of psychotherapy. It’s easy to grow cynical. And yet, findings from a recent study document when clinicians add — read more
-
Good Intentions or The Proverbial “Road to Hell?”: Trying to Understand the APA guidelines for Men and Boys
Several weeks ago, the American Psychological Association (APA) released its latest in a series of practice guidelines for psychologists – this time for “Psychological Practice with Boys and Men.” Prior years had seen guidelines focused on ethnicity, older adults, girls and women, LGBT, and “transgender and gender-non-conforming” persons. Curiously, despite claiming to be based on — read more
-
Surfing and Psychotherapy (or, How Two of My “Love Affairs” in Life are Alike)
I’m neither a great psychotherapist or surfer. I love doing both, however. Turns out, the two share a fundamental similarity critical to successful execution; in a word, responsiveness. /rəˈspänsivnəs/ NOUN The quality of reacting quickly and positively. In surfing, you take advantage of the waves coming your way. In psychotherapy, you utilize and react to what — read more
-
Time for a New Paradigm? Psychotherapy Outcomes Stagnant for 40 years
You’ve heard it said before. Flying is the safest form of transportation. Facts back up the claim. In fact, it’s not even close. In terms of distance traveled, the fatality rate per billion kilometers is .003, improving dramatically over the years. Cars, by contrast, are almost 1,000 times more dangerous. Still, since 1923, the fatality rate in — read more
-
Beating the Dodo Verdict: Can Psychotherapy Ever Achieve Better Results?
Nearly two decades have passed since I met Saul Rosenzweig at his home in St. Louis, Missouri. He was well into his nineties and still working every day. Truth is, I was surprised to learn he was still alive! In 1936, he’d penned an article –three and a half pages in total– that became one of — read more
-
“Clients Won’t Like It” and Other Concerns about Feedback Informed Treatment
In my travels each year, I meet 1,000’s of clinicians–professionals who truly want to help others, and are willing to try almost anything to do so. That’s why I always “lean in” whenever one expresses concern about the rising popularity of using formal measures of progress and the therapeutic relationship to inform and improve the — read more