-
Want to be more effective? Point North!
Sime time ago, while on a flight, I watched a program from the Discovery Channel about the North American red fox. The furry little creatures were shown hunting rodents hidden under three feet of snow. Three feet! Up in the air the foxes would hop, thrusting their noses deep into the drifts. Most of the time, — read more
-
The Sounds of Silence: More on Research, Researchers, and the Media
A while ago, I wrote about an article that appeared in The Guardian, one of the U.K.’s largest daily newspapers. Citing a single study published in Denmark, the authors boldly asserted, “The claim that all forms of psychotherapy are winners has been dealt a blow.” Sure enough, that one study comparing CBT to psychoanalysis, found — read more
-
Is your therapy making your clients worse? The Guardian Strikes Again
A while ago, an article appeared in The Guardian, one of the U.K.’s largest daily newspapers. “Counselling and Therapy can be Harmful,” the headline boldly asserted, citing results of a study yet to be published. It certainly got my attention. Do some people in therapy get worse? The answer is, most assuredly, “Yes.” Research dating — read more
-
What can therapists learn from the CIA? Experts versus the "Wisdom of the Crowd"
What can we therapists learn from the CIA? In a phrase, “When it comes to making predictions about important future events, don’t rely on experts!” After a spate of embarrassing, high-profile intelligence failures, a recent story showed how a relatively small group of average people made better predictions about critical world events than highly-trained analysts with access to classified information. — read more
-
Do you know who said, "Sometimes the magic works, sometimes it doesn’t"?
Well, do you? It was Chief Dan George playing the role of Old Lodge Skins in the 1970 movie, “Little Big Man.” Whether or not you’ve seen or remember the film, if you’re a practicing therapist, you know the wisdom contained in that quote. No matter how skilled the clinician or devoted the client, “sometimes therapy works, sometimes it — read more
-
How not to be among the 70-95% of practitioners and agencies that fail
Our field is full of good ideas, strategies that work. Each year, practitioners and agencies devote considerable time and resources to staying current with new developments. What does the research say about such efforts? When it comes to the implementation of new, evidence-based practices, traditional training strategies routinely produce only 5% to 30% success rates. Said another way, 70-95% of training fails — read more
-
Good News and Bad News about Psychotherapy
Have you seen this month’s issue of, “The National Psychologist?” If you do counseling or psychotherapy, you should read it. The headline screams, “Therapy: No Improvement for 40 Years.” And while I did not know the article would be published, I was not surprised by the title nor it’s contents. The author and associate editor, — read more
-
Do you do psychotherapy?
You know psychotherapy works. Forty years of research evidence backs up your faith in the process. And yet, between 1998 and 2007, psychotherapy use decreased by 35%. People still sought help, they just went elsewhere to get it. For instance, use of psychotropic drugs is up 40% over the last decade. A recent article in — read more
-
NIMH Dumps the DSM-5: The No News Big News
Some time ago, I blogged about results from field trials of the soon-to-be-released, fifth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders. Turns out, many of the diagnoses in the “new and improved” version were simply unreliable. In fact, the likelihood of two clinicians, applying the same criteria to assess the same person — read more
-
Evidence-based Practice is a Verb not a Noun
Evidence-based practice (EBP). What is it? Take a look at the graphic above. According to American Psychological Association and the Institute of Medicine, there are three components: (1) the best evidence; in combination with (2) individual clinical expertise; and consistent with (3) patient values and expectations. Said another way, EBP is a verb. Why then — read more
-
What to Pay Attention to in Therapy?
A week or so ago, I received an email from my friend, colleague, and mentor Joe Yeager. He runs a small listserve that sends out interesting and often provocative information. The email contained pictures from a new and, dare I say, ingenious advertising campaign for Colgate brand dental floss. Before I give you any of — read more
-
S.A.M.S.H.A. designates Feedback-Informed Treatment an "Evidence-based Practice"
(This post is included for historical purposes. Following the 2016 election, the NREPP registry was decommissioned) February 2, 2013 Chicago, Illinois USA I am honored to announce that Feedback-Informed Treatment (FIT) has been added to SAMSHA’s official database of evidence-based practices (EBP) known as NREPP (the National Registry of Evidence-based Programs and Practices). Briefly, NREPP — read more
-
Curing Clinician Overconfidence: Try Darting and Frowning
Overconfidence. It’s a problem that leads to systematic errors in judgement. Long thought to arise out of hubris or the corrupting effects of the emotion, the evidence actually shows it to be built into humans’ evolved cognitive machinery. Existimo ergo certus sum (I think, therefore I am…certain). Behavioral health professionals are not immune. The first — read more
-
Dealing with Scientific Objections to the Outcome and Session Rating Scales: Real and Bogus
The available evidence is clear: seeking formal feedback from consumers of behavioral health services decreases drop out and deterioration while simultanesouly improving effectiveness. When teaching practitioners how to use the ORS and SRS to elicit feedback regarding progress and the therapeutic relationship, three common and important concerns are raised: How can such simple and brief scales provide — read more
-
The Importance of "Whoops" in Improving Treatment Outcome
“Ring the bells that still can ring, Forget your perfect offering There is a crack in everything, That’s how the light gets in.” Leonard Cohen, Anthem Making mistakes. We all do it, in both our personal and professional lives. “To err is human…,” the old saying goes. And most of us say, if asked, that we agree — read more
-
What is the Real Source of Effectiveness in Smoking Cessation Treatment? New Research on Feedback Informed Treatment
When it rains, it pours! Growing interest in FIT is leading to the publication of research articles on its application in different contexts — an article on using the ORS and SRS in smoking cessation treatment, another a long-awaited article on the validity and reliability of the Group Session Rating Scale, and finally, a piece — read more
-
An Easy Way to Improve Our Schools (and Psychotherapy)
There is this article that appeared a while ago in the Atlantic Monthly that stuck with me. In it, Amanda Ripley detailed a simple and straightforward method for improving the performance of the public schools: have kids grade teachers. What kind of grades you ask? Not those on standardized achievement tests, and certainly not measures of — read more
-
Thomas Szasz, M.D.: Memories of a Friend and Mentor
Very early in the morning of December 9th, 2009, I received a call in my hotel room. My long time colleague and mentor, Jeffrey Zeig was on the other end. "May I ask you a favor?" he said. "Of course," I instantly replied, completely unaware of what was coming. "Tom Szasz is caught in a… — read more
-
Barriers to seeking mental health care
With all the challenges facing the profession, it is important to highlight people and organizations that are working hard to make a difference. On that note, tomorrow, Tuesday the 25th of September 2012 is the very first National Psychotherapy Day. Having a day of unified, active promotion of psychotherapy is the brain child… — read more
-
Looking for Results in All the Wrong Places: What Makes Feedback Work?
As anyone knows who reads this blog or has been to one of my workshops, I am a fan of feedback. Back in the mid-1990’s, I began using Lynn Johnson’s 10-item Session Rating Scale in my clinical work. His book, Psychotherapy in the Age of Accountability, and our long relationship, convinced me that I… — read more